The stock market's upward trajectory has seen a change in leadership roles. Technology stocks were at the forefront in the initial months, reminiscent of 2023. However, by the mid-year mark, small-cap stocks, once deemed outdated, experienced a surprising resurgence, albeit fleeting. In early August, a disappointing U.S. jobs report reignited recession concerns, causing investors to gravitate towards low-beta, defensive stocks.
By September, with economic indicators signaling a stronger economy, the spotlight turned to cyclical stocks that are sensitive to economic conditions. This trend has been further accelerated following the election, with optimism surrounding potential tax reductions, deregulation, and a revival in American manufacturing. The prevalence of cyclical stocks could potentially extend into 2025, given the anticipated robust growth and reemergence of manufacturing activities.
Shifting from Recession Fears to Growth Expectations
Against a backdrop of improving economic forecasts, there has been a notable shift towards cyclical stocks. Investors, like economists, are recognizing the remarkable resilience of the U.S. economy. Bloomberg reports indicate that the consensus forecast for 2024 real GDP has risen to 2.7%, up from 1.2% in January and just above 2% as recently as August.
According to recent trends, the upward revision in estimates has been propelled by the enduring strength of U.S. consumer spending. Bloomberg's consensus estimate for 2024 real consumer spending was 2.6% in November, nearly double the figure at the start of the year.
While most economists predict a slight deceleration in growth for 2025, even these forecasts are showing signs of improvement. The consensus forecast for trend growth is around 2.1%, a significant increase from the August low of 1.7%. This optimism is bolstered by ongoing strength in the labor market and indications of recovery in the manufacturing sector. In November, the ISM Manufacturing New Orders index climbed to 50.4, its highest level since early spring.
The Appeal of Cyclical Stocks
Beyond the promising growth outlook, another reason to consider cyclical stocks is their relative value. It's important to highlight that, with the S&P 500 Index trading at 22x next year's earnings, there are few absolute bargains, with the exception of the energy sector. However, when compared to the technology sector and related companies, cyclical stocks appear more reasonable. Financials and Industrials are trading near their 10-year average (refer to Chart 1). While the consumer discretionary sector trades at a premium relative to its historical valuation, much of this is attributed to internet retail and electric vehicle (EV) companies. Excluding these two sectors, which have a significant influence on the sector index, the valuations are more reasonable.
Chart 1
Global Equity Valuation by Sector
Source: LSEG Datastream, MSCI, and BlackRock Investment Institute. Nov 21, 2024.
Notes: The bars represent the current 12-month forward P/E ratios of MSCI sector indexes. The dots represent the 10-year average for each sector. P/E ratios are based on I/B/E/S earnings estimates for the next 12 months.
Quality in Cyclical Investments
As we approach 2025, I recommend an overweight position in cyclicals, particularly in financials, aerospace, and select consumer discretionary stocks. There is also potential in certain segments of the technology sector, including specific semiconductor companies. A word of caution: maintain a focus on quality. This entails prioritizing companies with high profit margins, a history of consistent earnings, and low debt over more speculative entities. While the economy is expected to maintain its steady progress, the current low volatility environment is unlikely to last forever. Investing in higher-quality names will assist in managing risk when the current enthusiasm fades and volatility returns.